Klaviyo vs Mailchimp: Which Email Platform is Best for Ecommerce?
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Quick Verdict
| Criteria | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Best for Ecommerce | Klaviyo | Purpose-built for ecommerce, SMS included, product recommendations |
| Best Value for Small Store | Mailchimp | Free plan, lower starting cost |
| Best ROI | Klaviyo | 30-50x ROI, higher revenue per customer |
| Easiest to Use | Mailchimp | Simpler interface, less features to learn |
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Klaviyo | Mailchimp |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing Model | Revenue-based | Per-contact based |
| Free Contacts | 250 | 500 |
| SMS Included | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Product Recommendations | ✅ Advanced | ⭕ Basic |
| Best For Revenue | $50k+ annual | Under $50k annual |
Executive Summary
Klaviyo and Mailchimp serve different ecommerce store types. Mailchimp is better for small stores under $50k annual revenue wanting to keep costs low. Klaviyo is better for stores generating $50k+ annually seeking higher email revenue and SMS capabilities.
Key Differences:
- 💰 Pricing: Mailchimp is per-contact; Klaviyo is revenue-based
- 📱 SMS: Klaviyo includes SMS; Mailchimp doesn't
- 🤖 AI: Klaviyo has AI product recommendations; Mailchimp is basic
- 🎯 Focus: Klaviyo specializes in ecommerce; Mailchimp is all-purpose
- 💡 ROI: Klaviyo clients report 20-50% revenue increase; Mailchimp more modest
Klaviyo Overview
Klaviyo is email and SMS platform purpose-built for ecommerce. 30,000+ ecommerce brands use Klaviyo because it's designed specifically for their needs. Revenue-based pricing means you only pay more when you're making more money.
Why Klaviyo for Ecommerce
- ✅ SMS marketing built-in (texts can 5x email ROI)
- ✅ Product recommendations engine (powers 10-20% of revenue)
- ✅ Shopify revenue tracking and attribution
- ✅ Behavior-based segmentation (browse history, purchase history)
- ✅ Mobile-first templates optimized for phones
Mailchimp Overview
Mailchimp is all-in-one marketing platform for small businesses. 12 million users include ecommerce store owners, but it's not specialized for ecommerce like Klaviyo. Good for testing email marketing without big investment.
Why Mailchimp for Small Stores
- ✅ Free plan up to 500 contacts
- ✅ Includes CRM, landing pages, and ads
- ✅ Shopify integration available
- ✅ Simpler interface, less to learn
- ✅ Lower cost for small lists
Frequently Asked Questions
At what revenue level should I switch to Klaviyo?
At $50,000+ annual revenue, Klaviyo ROI justifies the cost. At this level, Mailchimp would cost more per contact anyway. Klaviyo's SMS and product recommendations drive additional revenue growth.
How much will Klaviyo cost for a $100k store?
Typically $200-400/month depending on revenue-share agreement. But with 20-50% increase in email revenue from Klaviyo, the investment pays back many times over.
Can I use SMS with Mailchimp?
Mailchimp doesn't include SMS. You'd need separate platform like Twilio or Klaviyo. Klaviyo bundles SMS, making it simpler and usually cheaper than separate tools.
Should I migrate all contacts at once?
No, test with small segment first. Import engaged subscribers only, not your entire list. Monitor results for 2-3 weeks, then import remaining contacts when confident.
Can I use both Mailchimp and Klaviyo?
Technically yes, but not recommended. Leads to double emails, customer confusion, and wasted budget. Choose one platform and stick with it for 12+ months.
Final Recommendation
Best for Growing Ecommerce: Klaviyo
If you're serious about growing email revenue from your Shopify store, Klaviyo is the right choice. SMS marketing, product recommendations, and revenue-based pricing align with your growth goals.
Start Klaviyo Free →Best Value for Starting Out: Mailchimp
If you're just starting email marketing and want to keep costs down, Mailchimp's free plan is unbeatable. Test and learn email marketing at zero cost, upgrade to Klaviyo when revenue justifies it.
Try Mailchimp Free →